Industrial Sector and Capital Spending Trends

Industrial companies sell the capital goods that other businesses need to operate and grow. This creates a unique dynamic: industrial revenue depends on customer capex budgets, which move in cycles that can be tracked with leading indicators. Miss the cycle turn, and you're holding a high-beta sector at the wrong time. Catch it early, and industrials offer 2-3x market returns in the recovery phase. This article covers the indicators, metrics, and subsector dynamics that drive industrial sector performance.

The Industrial Capex Chain (Why Cycles Matter)

Industrial companies don't sell to consumers - they sell to businesses making capital allocation decisions. When corporate CFOs approve new factory equipment, expand fleet sizes, or build warehouse capacity, industrials benefit. When capex budgets get cut, industrial orders collapse.

The causal chain: Economic outlook → Corporate profits → Capex budgets → Industrial orders → Revenue/earnings

The lag matters: Industrial stocks typically lead the actual capex spending by 6-12 months because markets price in expected orders before they materialize.

Historical sensitivity:

• During the 2009 recovery, industrials returned +52% vs. S&P 500 +26%
• During the 2015-2016 manufacturing recession, industrials fell -12% while the S&P 500 was flat
• Industrials have a 1.15-1.25 beta to the broader market

The durable lesson: Industrials amplify the economic cycle. If you're right on the cycle direction, you're rewarded. If you're wrong, you suffer more than the market.

Leading Indicators (What to Watch)

ISM Manufacturing PMI

The Institute for Supply Management's Purchasing Managers Index surveys manufacturing executives monthly on new orders, production, employment, and supplier deliveries.

Reading the PMI:

Key sub-indices:

• New Orders (most forward-looking) - leads production by 1-3 months
• Backlog of Orders - indicates demand sustainability
• Customer Inventories - low inventories = future restocking demand

Historical pattern:

• PMI crossing above 50 from below → Industrials outperform next 6-12 months
• PMI crossing below 50 from above → Industrials underperform

Example (2020-2021):

• April 2020: PMI = 41.5 (COVID trough)
• June 2020: PMI = 52.6 (back to expansion)
• Industrial sector next 12 months: +68% return

The test: When PMI new orders drop below 50 while backlog remains elevated, the sector has 3-6 months of runway before revenue declines. This is your warning window.

Durable Goods Orders

The Census Bureau releases monthly data on new orders for manufactured goods expected to last 3+ years.

Key metrics:

• Total durable goods orders (volatile, includes aircraft)
• Core capital goods orders (ex-defense, ex-aircraft) - the cleanest business investment signal

3-month moving average guidance:

Why this matters: Core capital goods orders lead actual shipments by 2-4 months and lead industrial production by 3-6 months. A sustained downturn in orders signals industrial weakness ahead, even if current revenue looks fine.

Backlog Analysis (Revenue Visibility)

Many industrial companies report book-to-bill ratios and backlog levels that indicate future revenue.

Book-to-bill ratio:

Worked example - Boeing backlog:

• Total backlog (2024): ~5,000 aircraft worth $440+ billion
• Annual production capacity: ~400-500 aircraft
• Backlog duration: ~9-10 years

This extreme backlog provides exceptional revenue visibility but also means orders today don't ship for years.

Contrast - Industrial distribution:

• Fastenal book-to-bill: Near 1.0x (consumable products)
• Revenue visibility: 1-2 months maximum

The practical point: Not all backlog is equal. Multi-year backlogs in aerospace differ fundamentally from the short order books in industrial distribution.

Subsector Dynamics

Aerospace & Defense (25% of XLI)

Characteristics:

• Long production cycles (aircraft programs span decades)
• Government spending (defense) provides stability
• Commercial aerospace tied to airline capex and passenger traffic

Key metrics:

• Commercial aircraft orders and deliveries (Boeing, Airbus)
• Defense budget trajectory (U.S. DoD baseline ~$850B)
• Aftermarket revenue (high-margin parts and service)

Cycle sensitivity: Defense is counter-cyclical (government spending doesn't track GDP). Commercial aerospace is highly cyclical with multi-year leads and lags.

Machinery (20% of XLI)

Characteristics:

• Direct exposure to manufacturing capex
• Construction equipment tied to residential/non-residential building
• Agriculture equipment tied to crop prices and farm income

Key companies: Caterpillar, Deere, Illinois Tool Works

Leading indicators:

• Housing starts (construction equipment)
• Mining capex budgets (Caterpillar)
• Corn/soybean prices (Deere)

Example - Caterpillar cycle sensitivity:

• 2015-2016 mining downturn: Revenue fell -26% in two years
• 2021-2022 recovery: Revenue rose +22% in two years

Transportation (20% of XLI)

Sub-industries:

• Railroads (Union Pacific, CSX) - volume tied to industrial production
• Airlines (now mostly in XLY) - consumer and business travel
• Trucking (J.B. Hunt, Old Dominion) - freight demand indicator

Key metrics:

• Carloadings (rail) - tracks industrial output
• Truckload spot rates - leading indicator of freight demand
• Load-to-truck ratio - supply/demand balance

The freight signal: When truckload spot rates fall 15%+ from peak while inventory levels rise, it signals manufacturing is slowing before it shows in ISM data.

Building Products (10% of XLI)

Characteristics:

• Tied to residential and commercial construction
• Interest rate sensitive (mortgage rates affect housing)

Key indicators:

• Housing starts and permits
• Architecture Billings Index (ABI) - leads non-residential construction by 9-12 months

Working Capital Intensity (A Hidden Risk)

Industrials often carry significant working capital (inventory + receivables - payables) that consumes cash during growth phases.

Working capital intensity formula: Working Capital / Revenue = Days of capital tied up in operations

Sector comparison:

Why this matters: A machinery company with 35% working capital intensity that grows revenue $1 billion needs to fund $350 million in additional working capital. This cash outflow reduces free cash flow despite rising profits.

Worked example - Cash flow impact:

• Industrial company: $10B revenue, 30% working capital intensity
• Current working capital: $3B
• Revenue grows to $12B (+20%)
• New working capital need: $3.6B
• Cash consumed by growth: $600M

The practical point: When evaluating industrial companies, free cash flow conversion (FCF / Net Income) matters more than earnings growth. A company with 100% FCF conversion self-funds growth; one at 50% conversion needs external capital.

FCF conversion benchmarks:

• Above 100%: Excellent (includes depreciation benefit)
• 80-100%: Good
• 60-80%: Acceptable
• Below 60%: Investigate working capital or capex intensity

Industrial Sector Analysis Checklist

Essential (High ROI)

Framework questions before any industrial position:

• PMI trajectory - above or below 50, and rising or falling?
• Core capital goods orders - 3-month trend direction?
• Backlog health - is book-to-bill above 1.0?
• FCF conversion - is the company converting earnings to cash?

High-Impact (Cycle Timing)

For active sector allocation:

• Track ISM new orders sub-index monthly
• Monitor durable goods releases (typically 3rd week of month)
• Watch freight indicators (trucking spot rates, rail carloadings)
• Compare industrial sector relative strength to S&P 500

Optional (Subsector Selection)

For concentrated positions:

• Housing starts/permits (building products exposure)
• Commercial aircraft order trends (aerospace)
• Commodity prices (machinery linked to mining/agriculture)
• Defense budget outlook (fiscal year analysis)

Quantifying the Cycle (A Worked Example)

Scenario: ISM PMI just crossed above 50 after 6 months below

Historical precedent (last 5 occurrences since 1990):

Portfolio action: If your industrial allocation is 10% (market weight) and you believe the PMI signal is valid:

• Overweight to 15% (+ 5 percentage points)
• Expected excess return if historical pattern repeats: ~2% portfolio impact

The risk: PMI can give false signals. In 2019, PMI crossed above 50 in March but re-crossed below in August as trade tensions flared. Industrial returns were muted.

Risk management: Require 2 consecutive months above 50 before acting, and set a -10% stop-loss from entry if PMI reverses.

Next Step (Put This Into Practice)

Build a monthly monitoring dashboard with three leading indicators.

How to do it:

1. Bookmark the ISM Report on Business (released 1st business day of each month)
2. Track Census durable goods releases (around 26th of each month)
3. Add Cass Freight Index (monthly trucking data) for freight confirmation

Interpretation:

• All three improving: Strong industrial cycle signal
• Mixed signals: Neutral, maintain market weight
• All three deteriorating: Defensive positioning warranted

Action: If PMI new orders falls below 50 while your industrial allocation exceeds 12% of your equity portfolio, reduce to market weight (10%) within 30 days. The leading indicators are warning you.